Redirect Tracer vs Redirect Detective

Redirect Detective is a free online redirect checker that shows the full redirect chain for any URL. Redirect Tracer is a web-based redirect chain analysis tool. Both solve the same problem — paste a URL, see every redirect hop — but they differ in depth, presentation, and what you can do with the results.

This is a direct competitor comparison between two tools built for the same purpose.

The Quick Version

Redirect Detective provides a clear redirect chain display with status codes and URLs for each hop. Redirect Tracer provides the same core trace with added depth — full response headers, hop-by-hop timing, and more detailed chain visualization. Both work. Redirect Tracer goes further.

Both get the basic job done

If you need to see where a URL redirects, both tools will tell you. The difference is in what else they show you — and for debugging redirect problems, those details matter.

Feature Comparison

Feature	Redirect Detective	Redirect Tracer
Basic redirect tracing	Yes	Yes
Status code display	Yes	Yes
Chain visualization	Table with hops	Detailed visual chain
Full response headers	Partial — some headers shown	Yes — all headers per hop
Timing per hop	No	Yes
User-agent selection	Yes — desktop/mobile	Yes
Bulk URL checking	No	Yes
Redirect loop detection	Yes	Yes — with detailed analysis
Monitoring	No	Yes
Price	Free	Free tier available

How Redirect Detective Works

Redirect Detective presents a clean interface where you enter a URL and select a user-agent (desktop or mobile). The tool follows the redirect chain and displays each hop in a table showing the HTTP status code, URL, and server information.

One useful feature is the ability to switch user-agents, which helps identify redirects that behave differently for mobile vs desktop visitors. The results are presented clearly and are easy to read.

Redirect Detective has been a reliable free tool for years. It does what it says, and the user-agent switching is a thoughtful feature that not all redirect checkers include.

How Redirect Tracer Works

Redirect Tracer follows the same basic workflow — enter a URL, see the chain — but provides more data at each hop. Full response headers, timing information, and a visual chain format that makes it easy to see the complete redirect structure.

The additional detail is particularly useful when debugging. Seeing the complete set of headers for each hop reveals caching directives, security headers, and server configuration details that affect redirect behavior. Timing data shows exactly where latency accumulates in a chain.

For ongoing redirect management, Redirect Tracer supports bulk URL checking and monitoring to catch changes over time.

Pricing Comparison

Redirect Detective is completely free with no paid tier. It is ad-supported.

Redirect Tracer offers free instant tracing with no signup required for your first check. Extended features including bulk checking and monitoring are available on paid plans.

Try Redirect Tracer free

Trace redirect chains instantly. No signup required for your first check.

When to Choose Redirect Detective

Best for quick, free redirect checks

When you need a fast, no-frills answer to "where does this URL redirect?" with no signup or payment.

Best for user-agent testing

When you need to see how a redirect chain behaves differently for desktop vs mobile user-agents.

Best for occasional spot checks

When redirect checking is something you do rarely and you just need a reliable free tool.

When to Choose Redirect Tracer

Best for technical redirect debugging

When you need full response headers and timing data to diagnose exactly why a redirect chain is misbehaving.

Best for bulk redirect verification

When you need to check dozens or hundreds of URLs after a site migration and verify they all resolve correctly.

Best for redirect monitoring over time

When you need to track redirect behavior and get alerted when chains change, break, or gain unexpected hops.

Our Honest Take

Redirect Detective is a solid, reliable tool for basic redirect chain checks. The user-agent switching feature is a nice touch, and the fact that it is completely free makes it accessible to everyone.

Where Redirect Tracer adds value is in the details. Full response headers, timing per hop, bulk checking, and monitoring are the features that matter when redirect analysis is more than an occasional task. If you are debugging a specific redirect problem, those extra data points are often exactly what you need to find the root cause.

For a quick check, either tool works. For ongoing redirect management and detailed debugging, Redirect Tracer provides the additional depth that turns a redirect check into a redirect analysis.

Part of Boring Tools -- boring tools for boring jobs.

Never miss a broken redirect

Trace redirect chains and detect issues before they affect your users and SEO. Free instant tracing.